Water Based Piezo plotters (Epson 9000/7000 -
Mutoh Falcon 4000/4100/6100 - Mimaki JV2-130 & Textjet, Roland HiFi Jet,
etc. are using two up to seven Seiko Epson 64 nozzle piezo heads DX3.
The black head is a 64 nozzles (channels) head and the color a 4 or 5* 64
nozzles (channels) head.
The reliability of the print head is 2 billions of droplets of 40 to 3
picoliter giving a 23 picoliter medium size for normal poster printing.
To be more precise, the various sizes possible for droplets are:
- Micro:
40 picoliter
- Ultra-micro: 11
picoliter
- Super-micro: 6
picoliter
- Hyper-micro: 3
picoliter
THE DX3 PRINTER HEAD
FOR DYE BASED INK
True 1440 x 720-dpi-resolution delivers text and line art that rivals an
Imagesetter. Innovative 6-color ink system (Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, Light
Cyan, Light Magenta and Black) provides astonishing photographic quality
and color gamut surpassing current systems offered by other companies.
Proprietary ASIC technology controls the printing process. The result?
Extremely high print-to-print and printer-to-printer consistency compared
to other thermal or continuous flow ink jet printers.
DX3 Epsons Dual Density Droplet technology offers precise 11-picoliter
dot size for remarkably small, clean, sharp dot placement.
With every printing possibilities, the medium size of a droplet can be
considered of 23 picoliter.
They are between 40 picoliter and 3 picoliter (EPSON Ultra MicroDot). In
between, there is the EPSON Ultra MicroDot with 11 picoliter and the EPSON
Super MicroDot with 6 picoliter of droplet sizes. Following the plotter
producer, the 3 & 6 picoliter possibilities are cancelled or not.
The plotter adapt following the printing for one or one other resolution
but the medium consumption is generally 23 picoliter/droplet, higher the
resolution, smaller the droplet, at 1440 dpi the droplet is at 3 picoliter.
LIFE
OF THE HEAD
The life of the head is limited at 128 billions of droplets per color and
no matter if the droplet is 40 or 3 picoliter, only counts the impulse to
produce the droplet.
We can calculate the theoretical volume of the life of the head as
following:
-
MicroDot:
5 liter 120 ml/color
-
Ultra-MicroDot: 1 liter 408 ml/color
-
Super-MicroDot: 768 ml/color
-
Hyper-microDot: 384 ml/color
The medium consumption in Mutoh Falcon 4100/6100 is giving a volume of
23-picoliter/droplet per channel or 2 liter 944 ml/color during full life
of the head.
The life is also limited in timing because the ink inside the head, short
the life of the piezo system by the influence of the solvent used to
produce the ink.
WARNING
Using the PIGMENTED ink short the life of the head for about 20% because
the pigment inside the ink is acting as one abrasive.
To avoid any problems like head stocking or so, we advise to clean the
heads with a cleaning flush after printing with pigmented ink.
It is very important to remember that these heads are build to use DYE
based ink jet inks. It is possible of course to use PIGMENTED ink inside
but the life of the head is shorter comparatively with one head printing
only with dye ink.
We advise to print with pigmented ink only if it is no possible to avoid
it. If you need to print for outdoor using with dry cold lamination, we
advise you to print with the Prim Jet Color's DYE UV RESISTANT ink.
Following the exposition, this ink resist from 6 months up to 12 months.
DX3 Piezo Head, Extract
of Epson 9000 data
|
Printing
Engine Specifications |
Printing Method |
* |
Micro Piezo DX3 drop-on demand ink jet
technology with a 6 color ink system including cyan, magenta,
yellow, light cyan, light magenta, and black |
Nozzle Configuration |
* |
Monochrome: |
64 |
* |
Color |
64 x 5 (cyan,
magenta, yellow, light cyan, light magenta) |
|
Resolution |
|
* 1440 x 720 dpi; 720 x 720; 720 x 360
dpi; 360 x 360 dpi |
|
Engine Reliability |
* |
Print head
life: |
2 000
million dots/nozzle |
|
Ink Cartridge Capacity |
* |
Ink
cartridge yield: |
220 ml
each color (6 colors total) |
* |
Ink type: |
Dye based ink |
*Web
of references: Epson USA,
http://files.support.epson.com/pdf/pro9k_/pro9k_pg.pdf
WARRANTY
The warranty gave by the OEMs is normally 6 months or 1.8 billions of
droplets per nozzle (channel). For a medium consumption of 23 picoliter
the warranty is, in fact, limited at 2 liter 355 ml of DYE ink per color.
The OEM are advising the printer that if the printer is using a compatible
ink, dye or pigmented, the warranty on the plotter is loose.
First, it is
no legal for the OEM to cancel the warranty on the full plotter if the end
user is using compatible ink.
Second, The OEM can only cancel the warranty concerning the printing
system in direct connection with the ink. How cost in reality this famous
warranty?
PRICE OF THE WARRANTY
The fact to buy OEM's cartridges to keep the warranty has one price.
The OEMs are only selling the ink in 220 ml cartridge for one price of,
about 99 / 119 (so 450 /
600 the liter) for
standard DYE Based ink and about 125 / 150 (or
570 / 750 the liter) for PIGMENTED based ink (Mutoh - Mimaki -
Roland). Seiko Epson the head producer do not sell pigmented ink.
Exception the plotters like the Mutoh RJ800 or the Epson 7000 & 7500 using
110 ml cartridge sold at 100 the cartridge ( 910 the liter)
for the black and the color at 92 the cartridge ( 836 the
liter)
Following the table showing how much you will spare using Prim Jet Color's
inks.
Sparing cost based on 11 cartridges or 2 liter 950 ml used to cover the
warranty in volume per color.
SPARING COSTS
SPARING COST FOR THE
BLACK COLOR
|
Volume |
Inks |
Buying Prices
|
Sparing cost |
Total |
|
|
OEM |
PJC |
|
|
|
220 ml |
DYE |
99.00 |
41.58 |
57.42 |
631.62 |
|
1 Liter |
DYE |
450.00 |
99.00 |
351.00 |
1 035.45 |
|
220 ml |
PIGMENT |
125.00 |
70.00 |
55.00 |
605.00 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
570.00 |
140.00 |
430.00 |
1 268.50 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
910.00 |
180.00 |
730.00 |
2 153.50 |
TOTAL SPARING COST FOR THE
3 COLOR HEAD
|
Volume |
Inks |
Buying Prices
|
Sparing cost |
Total |
|
|
OEM |
PJC |
|
|
|
220 ml |
DYE |
297.00 |
124.74 |
172.28 |
1
894.86 |
|
1 Liter |
DYE |
1
350.00 |
297.00 |
1
353.00 |
3
106.35 |
|
220 ml |
PIGMENT |
375.00 |
210.00 |
165.00 |
1
815.00 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
1
710.00 |
420.00 |
1
290.00 |
3
805.50 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
2
508.00 |
495.00 |
2
013.00 |
5
938.35 |
TOTAL SPARING COST FOR 4
COLOR PLOTTER
|
Volume |
Inks |
Buying Prices
|
Sparing cost |
Total |
|
|
OEM |
PJC |
|
|
|
220 ml |
DYE |
396.00 |
166.32 |
229.68 |
2
526.48 |
|
1 Liter |
DYE |
1
800.00 |
396.00 |
1
404.00 |
4
141.80 |
|
220 ml |
PIGMENT |
500.00 |
280.00 |
220.00 |
2
420.00 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
2
280.00 |
560.00 |
1
720.00 |
5
074.00 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
3
418.00 |
675.00 |
2
743.00 |
8
091.85 |
TOTAL SPARING COST FOR THE
5 COLOR HEAD (C/Y/M/ + LC/LM or + ORANGE / GREEN)
|
Volume |
Inks |
Buying Prices
|
Sparing cost |
Total |
|
|
OEM |
PJC |
|
|
|
220 ml |
DYE |
495.00 |
207.90 |
287.10 |
3
158.10 |
|
1 Liter |
DYE |
2
250.00 |
495.00 |
1
755.00 |
5
177.25 |
|
220 ml |
PIGMENT |
625.00 |
350.00 |
275.00 |
3
025.00 |
|
1 Liter |
PIGMENT |
2
850.00 |
700.00 |
2
150.00 |
6
342.50 |
Price of one head:
black or
color 240.00 + work
As you can notice bellow the money paid to keep a warranty of a piezo head
which cost Euro 240 + work, cost in fact up to 6342.50 for 5
pigmented colors.
Following an extract of FLAAR report about piezo head. FLAAR is an
independent association of specialized journalists in wide format
plotters.
FLAAR REPORT ABOUT PIEZO HEAD
Site prepared by the FLAAR, Digital Imaging Technology Center, a
non-profit research institute dedicated to assisting people learn how to
use advanced digital photography and digital imaging in their own work
http://www.large-format-printers.org/
Myth #1, piezo print heads are permanent.
Facts: The piezo print head people want to induce you to buy piezo print
heads on the premise that you save money.
Reality of the matter
Piezo print heads self-destructs more often then piezo printer people
would like you to know about. We have a report from one Roland user who
indicates his heads dont last much past 300 feet ( 100 meters) of
media.
Even Roland apparently told him the print heads had to be replaced every
year. So much for "permanent" print heads with piezo.
We also got another e-mail that said his head self-destructed if it ran
into dust or debris on the vinyl. If I remember correctly I believe it
was a Roland system.
Piezo print heads also self-destructs if they hit a ripple in the media
(caused by too much ink which causes the paper to bubble up). Piezo
print heads also self-destructs on at least one kind of Roland media;
this infamous media curls at the edges. This results in the print head
hitting the raised part of the curl every time the print head makes a
crash. Kiss your piezo print head goodbye. We have several reports on
this "head strike" problem; seems to be generic.
Roland has stopped selling this media but there is lots of it still
floating around.
If you leave your printer for 3 months without use, yes, any print head
will cog because the ink dries out and blocks everything. Most service
contracts will cover this to some degree; some warranties may cover
this. One Roland dealer quoted a price of over $ 500 for the
replacement, per print head (covers print head and the house call). So
thats $1000 if both your piezo heads get clogged or have a head-strike
or are otherwise Epson piezo-electric print heads are used in Bellise,
Epson, Roland, Mimaki, and Mutoh.
Mimaki is rebranded as Stork. Mutoh is rebranded as Agfa, I-Jet,
Accuplot, Kodak, Digital Painter and PrimJet of one of the sign
companies.
Realize however, that not all piezo heads are from Epson (some are from
Xaar)
Another Myth: " Piezo print heads do not clog"
In general piezo heads are known to get clogged nozzles quite often,
having to clean them requires ejecting ink through them. This process
takes time, and may use up quite a lot of ink!
If you have to print in a dusty environment remember that Roland is
definitely dust sensitive, even from the media itself, so be sure your
source of media is super dust-free.
As soon as we learn the degree to which other kinds of heads suffer
similar problems with dust or debris on the surface of the media we will
add those observations to this report. We update FLAAR reports sometimes
as often as every day.
Nonetheless, there is nothing wrong with Roland, Epson, Mimaki, or Mutoh
piezo print heads. The quality of a Roland printer is among our favorite
(as long as you get one that does not band). Piezo print heads do their
job quite well. 99% of users will unlikely lose a head because of dust
on the media.
But just dont presume the heads will last forever. We get the
impression that replacing piezo heads is more common (and more costly)
than most people realize.
So far the only place I have noticed a piezo print head claim to being
permanent is in the Gretag advertisement for its new Carolina textile
press. I quote: "Compared to thermal print heads, piezo heads are
permanent under normal operating conditions. (piezo heads) are designed
to last for the life of the printer. "I can only say that Gretag must be
using heads other than Epson heads, because not even a sales rep has
claimed the Epson heads are permanent. Roland heads in particular (from
Epson) bite the dust regularly.
OEM's Dye Ink Durability
It is well known and documented that Epson prints fade faster than almost
any other inkjet print. It is gradually becoming known that some Epson
paper will also discolor, under some circumstances.
I do not have much data on Roland, Mutoh, or Mimaki dye based inks but
there is certainly not much acceptance that they last as long as the inks
by Prim Jet Color or Encad for thermal print head designs.
OEM's Piezo Ink Durability
Studies in ink Durability vary between bait-and-switch to what a novice
would consider close to misleading. The most infamous case is the "200
year + claim by Epson for its new encapsulated inks.
I was at DRUPA trade show where these inks were premiered. I have it on
good authority that the ink chemistry was still not finished and that the
first inks which were used were judged unsatisfactory.
Back to the chemical laboratory. Thus the question arises (which few
people have asked in this manner), namely, how could anyone make a
Durability claim for an ink that was perhaps not the same ink actually
sold today? In any event, the Durability claim was cut in half shortly
thereafter.
All that said and done, the durability of fine art prints done with
a printer using Epson print heads may be less than you (or your clients)
expect.
The tests are based on darkened conditions, indeed Epson even admits that
prints from some of its printers must be sealed completely in glass or the
ozone alone will cause the cyan to react inappropriately, and evidently
within a matter of weeks or months. If you use a Roland remember that its
inks come via Epson, since the Roland uses the Epson print heads (as does
Mimaki and Mutoh).

|